James Dolan’s tenure as owner of the New York Knicks has been marked by continued disappointment and underperformance on the court. Over the past decade, the Knicks have struggled to find consistent success, making the playoffs only three times since the 2013-14 season. Their best performance came in 2020-21 when they finished fourth in the Eastern Conference but were eliminated in the first round of the playoffs.
Dolan’s leadership has been characterized by questionable decision-making and a lack of stability in the front office and coaching staff. He has been criticized for his hands-on approach, often interfering with basketball operations and making impulsive decisions. One of the most notable incidents was when he had former Knicks legend Charles Oakley forcibly removed from Madison Square Garden during a game, damaging the team’s relationship with fans and former players.
While Dolan’s willingness to spend money on the team is evident, his choices in personnel and management have often backfired. Hiring Phil Jackson as team president in 2014 was a high-profile move that ultimately failed to bring success to the franchise. Dolan’s tendency to prioritize splashy signings and trades over building a cohesive team has contributed to the Knicks’ inconsistent performance.
Michael Jordan, owner of the Charlotte Hornets, is another contender for the title of worst NBA owner. Since becoming majority owner in 2010, the Hornets have made the playoffs only twice, never advancing past the first round. Jordan’s tenure has been marked by poor draft decisions, such as selecting Michael Kidd-Gilchrist over Damian Lillard in 2012 and letting key players like Kemba Walker leave without adequate compensation.
Other Terrible NBA Owners
Jordan’s focus on profitability over competitiveness is evident in the Hornets’ being the only NBA team to have never paid the luxury tax. This reluctance to invest heavily in talent has hindered the team’s ability to attract and retain star players, leaving the franchise in a perpetual state of mediocrity.
Joe Tsai, owner of the Brooklyn Nets, has also faced criticism for handling the team. Since purchasing the Nets in 2019, Tsai has overseen a period of turmoil and underachievement. The high-profile acquisitions of Kevin Durant and Kyrie Irving initially brought excitement but ultimately led to disappointment and dysfunction.
Tsai’s decision-making has been questioned, particularly in handling the Kyrie Irving controversy and the subsequent trade demands from Irving and Durant. The Nets’ inability to build a cohesive team culture and capitalize on their star talent has led to early playoff exits and a failure to meet expectations.
Last Word
Long-suffering New York Knicks fans deserve better than the decades of mismanagement and disappointment under James Dolan’s ownership. The once-proud franchise, with its rich history and passionate fanbase, has been reduced to a laughingstock of the league. Year after year, fans have watched as their team makes questionable decisions, fails to attract top free agents, and struggles to build a winning culture.
The constant cycle of false hope followed by crushing disappointment has taken its toll on the fanbase. Madison Square Garden, once known as the “Mecca of Basketball,” now serves as a reminder of what could have been. It’s high time for a change at the top, for an owner who understands the game, respects the franchise’s legacy, and is committed to bringing championship basketball back to New York City. Knicks fans have shown unwavering loyalty through thick and thin, and they deserve an owner who matches their passion and dedication to the team.
